25 August 2024
2004 Olympic Baseball: Australia wins Olympic silver after Cuba wins dramatic Gold Medal match
by Robert Laidlaw | Greece, August 25, 2004 –
This story is part of a series running on baseball.com.au from August 15-25 commemorating the 20-year anniversary of the 2004 Australian Olympic Baseball team. Each day will feature a recap and story as if the tournament is happening now. Scroll to bottom of this story for more links and recaps.
PROUD AUSTRALIA WINS SILVER

ATHENS – AUGUST 25: Silver medal winning team of Australia pose for a picture after receiving their medals during the medal ceremony for baseball on August 25, 2004 during the Athens 2004 Summer Olympic Games at the Baseball Centre in the Helliniko Olympic Complex in Athens, Greece. (Photo by Nick Laham/Getty Images)
Although Australia lost the gold medal game 6-2 in the 2004 Olympic baseball tournament in Greece, a silver medal was still a worthy prize for all the hard work.
But the gold medal could have been the Aussies with a bit of luck, as several controversial decisions went against them in the game.
The first was in the bottom of the fourth with Australia trailing 2-0. Australia had two runners on-base and two out when Tom Brice smashed the ball over the centrefielder’s head.
Brice had a three ball, one strike count on him when he unloaded with the big hit, which seemed to hit the home run fence as Cuban centrefielder Carlos Tabares juggled the catch. Replays would suggest otherwise.
WATCH THE REPLAY: 2004 Olympic Gold Medal Game
Tabares held the glove up in the air triumphantly and the umpire signalled an out, which retired the side.
Australian manager Jon Deeble argued the call long and hard, which caused his ejection.
The second major controversy came at the top of the sixth, when Cuba had two runners on and no outs, when catcher Ariel Pestano appeared to have upset the home plate umpire and was thrown out of the game.
After a long delay and arguments from the Cubans, Pestano was allowed to continue his at bat, which visibly upset the Australians, as they then proceeded to concede four runs and fell 6-1 behind.

BOX SCORE AND PLAY-BY-PLAY: Click here for detailed stats and box score
Starting pitchers John Stephens for Australia and Cuban Norge Vera were in control early, with neither side able to score through the first three innings.
At the top of the fourth, Osmani Urrutia ran out an infield single and Frederich Cepeda smashed a long home run – 2-0 Cuba.
Then the bottom of the fourth, where it seemed the Aussies were back in it but for the third out call made against Brice.
David Nilsson had walked and, with two out, Andrew Utting singled. But both were left stranded after that controversial call on Brice’s hit.
In the bottom of the fifth, Paul Gonzalez led of with a home run – what could have been? Australia was back in the game, just one run behind at 2-1.
But then the top of the sixth happened, which in the end was the deciding rally that won Cuba the gold medal.
Urrutia and Cepeda both collected singles, before Pestano’s at bat, which, after he was reinstated, collected a single up the middle to load the bases. Eriel Sanchez then collected a two-run hit, and it saw Stephens relieved on the mound by Ryan Rowland-Smith.
After Danny Miranda put two runners in scoring position with his sacrifice bunt, and with two out, Eduardo Paret hit a two-run double and it was 6-1 Cuba.
There was only one more run scored in the game, when in the bottom of the eighth, Utting and Brice collected two out walks, and Brett Tamburrino had a RBI single, for Australia’s second run.
Cuban reliever Adiel Palma pitched 3.2 innings for the win, conceding four hits and three walks for five strikeouts. Aussie starter Stephens took the loss, giving up 10 hits and no walks in five frames, for three K2s.
“The feeling afterwards was weird,” said Aussie outfielder Tom Brice. “There was the excitement of the day before, beating Japan. Going in, if we lost we still get a silver medal. It’s strange, you go out to win but the result is still better than expected going into the Olympics.”

The silver medal still tastes sweet.
“We didn’t win but came away with something amazing. I don’t think there are any other cases like that, you’re not the champion team but an Olympic silver medal will follow me forever,” he says.
For David Nilsson it was one of the toughest moments as a competitor he had experienced.
On balance, Nilsson had a wonderful MLB career, was the first Aussie to make the All-Star game (1999), and had been the MVP of Australia’s thrilling gold medal win against Cuba in the 1999 Intercontinental Cup, as well as playing in the 2000 Olympics.
But always striving for his best, Nilsson was disappointed in not winning an Olympic gold medal.
“In the locker room after game I did not feel we won silver, I felt we lost an opportunity for gold and was really shattered,” Nilsson said.
“But at the same time, we were silver medallist at the Olympics, so 15 minutes afterwards, I kept it (disappointment) to myself, as I did not want to spoil the moment. I was just frustrated about some of the things that happened,” he adds. “Then when we went out to the medal ceremony, and standing with the team, with silver around my neck, it was a wonderful moment. But, while it was one of the best moments in sport, it was still one of the most frustrating and disappointing.”

ON THE TOM BRICE HIT TURNED CATCH…
That ‘fly’ ball by Brice in the bottom of the fourth inning was a huge turning point in the game, as it could have set up a different outcome.
“My approach with a three balls and one strike count was to sit on a good pitch I could drive, and I was ready,” Brice said. “Sure enough, it was a fast ball down the middle, a bit of a cookie. The ball wasn’t carrying that day and initially I did not feel I hit it as far as I did.”
It carried far and camera angles seem to show a clear hit.
“There was some back spin on the ball, so it travelled further. As I ran down the line, I saw the outfielder run into fence, but did not see the ball, so thought it went over, until I saw the centrefielder with his glove in the air and massive smile on his face.”
“I was none the wiser, and thought he made an amazing play. It went from thinking I had hit a three-run homer, to us being out of the innings. But when I returned to the dugout the chatter was that the ball had popped out and hit the fence before it was caught, so it should have been a hit.”
“(Jon) Deeble was insistent in arguing the point longer than he would normally, and as it turned out, he was 100 percent right.”
“After the fact, it’s one of those things, the ump called me out, it is what it is, move on. Obviously annoying but sport sometimes goes your way, sometimes not.”
“It was the biggest game I played in. That’s sport, that’s life, it cannot be changed, so no point in dwelling on it.”
Here’s what Dave Nilsson had to say…
“As for Tom’s (Brice) hit, we thought we saw it clearly hit the fence from the dugout, but maybe it didn’t? It looked clear from where we were. The stuff that happens, with officiating, things that happen. I bit my lip at the interview after the game.”
“And when one of their main hitters was thrown out for arguing, I was right there. It was shocking (to see him back in the game).”
And Jon Deeble…
Jon Deeble knew in his heart the Tom Brice ball had hit the fence and wasn’t going to just let sleeping dogs lie, and argued hard for his team but to no avail, earning an ejection.
Although it’s never nice to be thrown out of a big game, Deeble stood up for his charges and fought tooth and nail for what he believed in, which is part of the reason Australia did so well in the Olympic campaign.
“My take, I thought it hit the fence,” Deeble said. “As a ran out of the dugout on the third base side, a cameraman told be it clearly hit the fence and wasn’t a catch, so I was confident in arguing our point.”
“But the umpires that day did not speak much English, which was frustrating. I went to the chief umpire and told him that ‘you guys need to get together’ but he refused to do it. It was so disappointing, and a kick in the guts.”
“Playing Cuba, when they get behind they start arguing, so I thought we could have won that gold medal, if that call had gone our way.”
“As for winning a silver medal, it’s something we should celebrate, as it’s still a magnificent achievement.”
Paul Gonzalez on his Gold Medal game homer
Instead of being Australia’s first run of the gold medal game with his homer in the fifth inning, Paul Gonzalez could have been the go-ahead run and the game situation could have been changed in Australia’s favour.
“While my home run kept us in it, who knows what would have happened if Tom Brice’s hit had been ruled fair,” Gonzalez said.
“Cuba plays with emotional momentum, and we had almost knocked them out of their mental state – they use so much emotion.
“If Tom’s hit had been called safe, the game would have seen us ahead, rather than 2-0 behind – it was a complete game changer. We had the arms to keep us in the ballgame if we were ahead.”
Other stories:
– Semi Final Recap: Australia vs Japan
– Game 7 Recap: Australia vs Canada
– Game 6 Recap: Australia vs Netherlands
– Game 5 Recap: Australia vs Greece
– Game 4 Recap: Australia vs Japan
– Game 3 Recap: Australia vs Italy
– Game 2 Recap: Australia vs Chinese Taipei
– Game 1 Recap: Australia vs Cuba
– Preview: Australia looks to learn from success and failures past ahead of 2004 Olympics
– Roster: Meet the 2004 Australian Olympic Baseball team




















“In 1999 it worked well, as the tournament (Intercontinental Cup) was in November and I had finished my season with Milwaukee after breaking my thumb six weeks earlier,” Nilsson said.


